The AI threat to employee mental health, and why investors need to care
The spectrum of possibilities presented by the artificial intelligence (AI) revolution is impossibly wide. It ranges from significant improvements in economic productivity, the promise of unprecedented abundance and leisure, to the creation of humanity-destroying super intelligence.
But it is a safe bet that AI will transform the workplace. It is already automating many existing tasks, generating enormous efficiencies and creating entirely new types of work.
As companies take advantage of the opportunities presented by this new technology, it presents them with formidable challenges – not least in managing its impact on the wellbeing of their employees. Studies are already finding that AI adoption is increasing stress felt by employees, posing risks to employee mental health and contributing to burnout.
If not carefully managed, the data suggests that employee anxiety around AI adoption could increase the already substantial costs that businesses face from poor employee mental health.
The economic costs of mental ill-health
Depression and anxiety alone cost the global economy more than $1trn in lost productivity each year, according to the WHO. AXA found that almost one in four workers globally took time off due to mental health challenges.
At CCLA, as investors, we are concerned both about the economic cost and the ethical responsibility companies and their shareholders have to address poor employee mental health .
We have been focused on this issue since 2021, when we sought to understand how different companies were performing in terms of the support they provide for their employees’ mental wellbeing. To do so, we designed a benchmark to objectively assess 100 leading listed UK employers and soon applied that benchmark to an equivalent global index.
We have now published five sets of results from the Global CCLA Mental Health benchmark. Our latest report shows where companies are making progress on this crucial issue – and where performance continues to lag.
An objective assessment
The benchmark assesses companies across 27 criteria, using information they have publicly disclosed. These criteria cover four themes: management commitment and policy; governance and management; leadership and innovation; and performance reporting and impact. The assessment generates a percentage point score, and constituents are grouped in five tiers.
Over the five years we have been assessing the global index constituents, performance has improved, but not markedly. The average score in 2026 was 30%, up from 25% in 2022.
That average hides significant regional disparities. Average scores in EMEA and Asia-Pacific are up 20 percentage points from 2022 to 2026. In North America, the average score has fallen by one percentage point.
A mixed picture on good practice adoption
Some elements of corporate mental health management are now ‘business as usual’. Almost all companies (94%) recognise mental health as a relevant issue for management focus, 98% provide employees with at least one support mechanism, such as employee counselling services, and 96% collect employee engagement data.
However, many elements of good practice are barely adopted. Only 15% of CEOs have publicly committed to workplace mental health. Only one in three have disclosed that they provide training to managers. Fewer than one in four (23%) say that they use employee engagement data they collect to inform their mental health strategy.
The tech sector is a persistent underperformer. Five of the magnificent seven tech giants – Alphabet, Apple, Meta, Nvidia and Tesla – are in the bottom tier. These companies are both large employers and operate in sectors where human capital drives financial performance. They can’t afford to neglect the mental health of their employees.
A tool for engagement
We believe there is a role for investors in encouraging companies in which they invest to promote good work practices that support mental wellbeing. The benchmark provides a useful tool for investors to engage with those companies whose performance is lagging. It is the foundation for an investor coalition on the issue that brings together investors collectively managing more than $10trn.
Our report recommends that companies make a leadership commitment, draw up a robust mental health policy and set and report on specific, measurable objectives.
It also encourages companies to support managers with training and practical tools and collaborate externally to advance best practice.
These actions pay dividends. Research by Deloitte found a return of £4.70 for every £1 spent on supporting employee mental health and wellbeing. During this period of change and uncertainty created by AI, that investment is likely to be well spent.